cjbanning: (The Bishop)
As preached at the service of Evening Prayer on Saturday, June 17 at St. Thomas' Episcopal Church in Glassboro, NJ.

Genesis 18:1-15, 21:1-7
Psalm 116:1, 10-17
Romans 5:1-8
Matthew 9:35-10:23

During the pandemic, Fr. Todd, Jonathan W---, and I had a Zoom book club going on in which we would read theology books and discuss them on Monday nights. At one point it was my turn to choose the next book, and I chose this, The Crucified God, because I already owned it and had been wanting to read something by the author, Jürgen Moltmann, for some time. Jonathan and Fr. Todd agreed and so I opened the book to read the introduction and first chapter, and found this inscribed into the first page. For those of you who cannot see, which is probably everybody, it says “George E. Council, 3/83.”

I don’t know what 3/83 means–is it the third of 83 books? Did he procure it in March of 1983?--but George E. Councell (pictured in my icon above) was of course the 11th bishop of New Jersey. He was ordained to the episcopate in 2003 and retired in 2013, being succeeded by our current bishop, William Stokes. Bishop Councell sadly passed away in 2018.

This book passed into my ownership at a diocesan convention where, knowing that he wanted to downsize his theological library, Bishop Councell set out a large number of his books, free to a good home. My parents will attest that I am constitutionally unable to refuse a free book, and the rest is history.

Sharing the contents of his library was only one of the ways that Bishop Councell shared his faith in Christ during his episcopate. In 2008, Bishop Councell laid his hands on me in the sacrament of confirmation. While some traditions allow priests to confirm under certain circumstances, in the Episcopal Church confirmation is exclusively the responsibility of the sacred order of bishops. And of course, Bishop Councell preached the Gospel of Jesus Christ in his leadership of the diocese by both word and example.

Our prayerbook catechism describes the ministry of a bishop as representing Christ and his Church, particularly as apostle, chief priest, and pastor of a diocese; guarding the faith, unity, and discipline of the whole Church; proclaiming the Word of God; acting in Christ’s name for the reconciliation of the world and the building up the Church; and ordaining others to continue Christ’s ministry.

Empowered by the holy grace of God, Bishop Councell fulfilled all of these roles faithfully and lovingly, as has Bishop Stokes after him.

In our Gospel reading this evening, Jesus summons the Twelve and gives to them a special authority. Anglicanism understands our current bishops to exist in continuity with the Twelve and to inherit their authority, even if there is not always agreement over the exact mechanism of that continuity. Former Archbishop of Canterbury Michael Ramsey describes “the essential function of the Apostles” as having a “two-fold significance”:
They are “sent” to bear witness to the historical events [of Jesus’ ministry], and they are officers of the one people of God, which is behind and before all local communities. As time goes on the form of the ministry develops; while in the apostolic age there was a local ministry of presbyter-bishops and deacons and a “general” ministry of Apostles, a change takes place, and in the second century century there appears the ministry of Bishops with a growing emphasis upon their necessity as links with the Apostles. [. . . ] And if the Apostles, by their place in the structure, set forth the Gospel, then there will be needed in subsequent ages a similar ministry [. . .] with a similar relation to the Gospel and the Body [i.e., the Church]. The Apostle, and the Bishop after[wards], is the link with the historic events and the organ of the one Body [of Christ].
Alongside the Scriptures, the Creeds, and the dominical sacraments of Baptism and Eucharist, the order of bishops is one of the four elements considered essential to the nature of the Church by Anglicans. It is so important that we in the United States call our Anglican province “the Episcopal Church,” where “episcopal” derives from the Greek “episcopos,” bishop.

As I’m sure most of you are aware, one week from today the office of the Bishop of New Jersey will pass from Bishop Stokes to our bishop-elect, the Rev. Canon Dr. Sally French, as she is ordained to the sacred order of bishops and becomes the 13th Bishop of New Jersey. She will also, of course, be the first ever female Bishop of New Jersey.

The episcopate, the order of bishops, exists as a visible sign of both the unity and the diversity of the universal Church: one, holy, catholic, and apostolic. It is only appropriate that the episcopate represent the entire range of genders and gender identities, of sexual orientations, of races and ethnicities and nationalities.

Jesus did not die just for the salvation of thirty-three year old Palestinian Jewish men, but for all of us. Just as Christ’s role as the firstborn of creation, the perfect model of all human beings, is not limited by the contingent features of his earthly existence, neither is our capacity to participate in his priesthood so limited.

Church of England bishop and Biblical scholar N.T. Wright articulates this concept by pointing out that “[p]art of the point of the new creation launched at Easter was the transformation of roles and vocations: from Jews-only to worldwide, from monoglot to multilingual (think of Pentecost [which we celebrated just a couple of weeks ago]), and from male-only leadership to male and female together.”

It is a contingent historical fact that the disciples named in Scripture as “The Twelve” were all men. And yet the Gospels and the Acts of the Apostles and the letters of St. Paul all speak of many women filling leadership roles in the early Church, performing the functional equivalent of Archbishop Ramsey’s description of the role of Apostle. Of particular significance are Mary of Magdala and the other women who stood as witnesses to the resurrection and conveyed that good news back to the Twelve, acting as “apostles to the apostles.” In St. Paul’s letter to the Romans, there is a mention of a Junia who is “well known” or “outstanding” “among the apostles,” which some interpret as Biblical evidence that the apostolate in the early-Church was not limited to a single gender.

In any case, patriarchy quickly reared its ugly head, and even the Church was not immune, resulting in nearly two millennia of an all-male episcopate. It has only been within my own lifetime that women have begun taking their place within the sacred order of bishops, starting with the ordination and consecration of the Rt. Rev. Barbara Harris in 1989, and even now it remains not without controversy, even within Anglicanism. Out of the 40 autonomous provinces which make up the world-wide Anglican Communion, only twelve have consecrated female bishops.

Jesus’ command to the Twelve in our Gospel reading is to “Go to the lost sheep of the house of Israel. As you go, declare publicly that the kingdom of heaven has arrived. Heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse people with skin diseases, cast out demons.” Bishop-Elect French will probably not have much call to raise the dead or heal lepers, but you can be certain that she will declare publicly that the kingdom of heaven has arrived. And while she most likely will not perform literal exorcisms, she will continue in her predecessors’ example, leading our diocese to confront head-on the demons of poverty, bigotry, and gun violence.

I invite all of us to support our new bishop with our prayers and actions as she starts her new ministry as apostle, chief priest, and pastor of our diocese, proclaiming the Word of God which cannot be chained, but is living and active.

Amen.
cjbanning: (Default)
 What is the function of the historic episcopate in the 21st century?

One assumes that the historic episcopate holds a function and purpose beyond the simple passing of apostolic authority from one generation to the next. (Or, to put it another way, that this apostolic authority needs to be actually constitutive of something.) To reply that its function lies in the preservation of doctrine seems problematic insofar as there presently seems to be as much diversity of opinion within the historic episcopate (which after all contains both John Shelby Spong and Benedict XVI) as there is outside it.

My intuition is that the historic episcopate acts as an extraordinary (there's a pun in there somewhere) sign to the world of the unity and catholicity of the Church of Christ. But how and why this is so I find myself, for the moment, unable to fully articulate. 

cjbanning: (Palm Sunday)
Fr. Dan Dunlap, writing at Catholic in the Third Millenium, nicely puts his finger on the way that both conservative and liberal approaches to the historicity of Scripture manage to miss the point completely:
[A]cademic honesty compels the scholar to admit that "proving" the historicity of the mythos is impossible. But then it should be noted that disproving the historicity of the mythos is just as certainly impossible (a fact that the likes of John Shelby Spong and company disingenuously dismiss). Simply put, the mythos – the very object of the Church's faith – is not subject to historical or scientific investigation (either in proof or disproof). Rather it transcends critical inquiry, while, paradoxically, benefiting in the many new ways of understanding the Faith that may thus emerge from such investigation into the biblical milieu itself.

[. . .]

The Christian Faith is not a belief in the historicity of the resurrection (as an end in itself), but rather faith in the resurrected Christ; it is not a belief in the historicity of the virgin birth (as an end in itself), but rather faith in the Christ who was born of a Virgin.
While Fr. Dan is, in my opinion, quite too quick to expel from the big tent of Christianity those who don't adhere to the doctrines that he and I see as central (e.g., the Trinity), he has an interesting view (which I can't disagree with) on how the apostolic churches (Anglicanism, Roman Catholicism, Eastern Orthodoxy, some parts of Lutheranism, etc.)  have a "unique and peculiar calling within the kingdom of God to preserve and guard what can be termed the 'Great Story' or 'True Myth' (in Lewis' sense)." I in particular agree that it's not always clear how the process of demythologization inherent in the type of liberal historicism represented by "the likes of John Shelby Spong and company" serves to achieve this aim, which in many ways is the argument I make in my post Why the Quest for the Historical Jesus is a Spiritual Dead-End. (All through college I was convinced, albeit falsely, that Protestantism simply had no place for any viewpoint other than either this sort of liberal historicism or else biblical literalism.)

Of course, a large part of why this resonates with me is my peculiar mix of a relatively low view of Scripture (without disagreeing that the Bible contains all that is necessary to salvation, whatever that means) and my relatively high ecclesiology, which makes me committed first and foremost to what Fr. Dan calls "the mythos to which the early fathers provided normative articulation in ancient creedal and doxological symbols that are with us to the present day -- preserved in the liturgies of the great apostolic churches."
cjbanning: (Trinity)
1. Godhead. The apophatic denial of God's non-existence.
2. Trinity. God is one Being in three Persons.
3. Chalcedonian Christology. Hypostatic union: Jesus Christ is two natures, one human and one divine, united into one Person.
4. Wesleyan Quadrilateral. Scripture, tradition, reason, and experience as complementary sources of revelation.
5. The Sacraments. The seven sacraments (baptism, Eucharist, confirmation, reconciliation, ordination, marriage, healing) are the means of sanctifying grace, rites in which God is uniquely active, visible signs of an invisible reality.
6. Ex opere operato. The seven sacraments are efficacious in and of themselves, by the very fact of the actions’ being performed, because Christ is at work in them in order to communicate the grace that each sacrament signifies.
7. Baptismal Regeneration. The salvation of baptized persons (including those baptized by blood or desire, as well as by water) is uniquely mediated through the sacrament.
8. Real Presence. Jesus Christ is really present in the Eucharist. (Radical transignification.)
9. Perseverance of Eucharistic Presence. Real Presence is not dependent on the act of drinking or eating and continues in the consecrated hosts beyond the celebration of the Eucharist.
10. Adorableness of the Eucharist. Worship may be properly rendered to the Blessed Sacrament.
11. One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church. The unity, holiness, catholicity, and apostolicity of the Church of Jesus Christ.
12. Apostolic Succession. The spiritual authority placed on the apostles by Christ is passed through history via the institutional rites of the Church, i.e. the consecration of bishops. The one Church of Christ subsists in the apostolic churches as governed by the historic episcopate.
13. Ordained Presbyterate. God specially calls some people (of all genders, races, and sexualities) to undergo the sacrament of ordination; to represent Christ and the Church of Christ, particularly as pastor to the people; to share with the bishop in the overseeing of the Church; to proclaim the Gospel; to administer the sacraments; and to bless and declare pardon in the name of God.
14. Free Will. God has willed that human persons remain under the control of their own decisions. For its part, authentic freedom is an exceptional sign of the divine image within a human being.
15. Sin. The existence of corporate evil—sexism and racism, transphobia and homophobia; poverty and hunger; totalitarianism and fascism—such that human freedom is curtailed and diminished.
16. Sola gratia. Since human freedom has been damaged by sin, only by the aid of God's grace can the Church bring the relationship between God and human beings into full flower.
17. Resistability of Grace. The free wills of human beings may cooperate with God so as to prepare and dispose themselves for the attainment of salvation; human wills can also refuse complying, if they please.
18. Universal Potential for Redemption. The birth, life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ are for the benefit of all humankind, not just an elect.
19. Kingdom of Heaven. Through grace, humans are called to use their free will to pray for peace, fight for justice, and build God’s Kin(g)dom on Earth.
20. Intercession of Saints. It is proper to pray to the Saints and ask for their intercessions.
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

My Prayer

"This is my prayer: that your love may overflow more and more with knowledge and full insight to help you to determine what is best."
-- St. Paul's Epistle to the Philippians 1:9-10

All entries copyrighted © 2009-2022 by Cole J. Banning

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Wednesday, 2 July 2025 12:54 pm

Style Credit